Back to main menu :: [Prev] what the fuck? [Next]

Some of the "Moral Values" we get to look forward to for the next four years:

Judge won't let woman divorce while she's pregnant

A Spokane woman trying to divorce her estranged husband two years after he was jailed for beating her has been told by a judge she can't get out of the marriage while she's pregnant.

The case pits a first-year attorney who argues that state law allows any couple to divorce if neither spouse challenges it against a longtime family law judge who asserts that the rights of the unborn child in this type of case trump a woman's right to divorce.

"There's a lot of case law that says it is important in this state that children not be illegitamized," Spokane County Superior Court Judge Paul Bastine told The Spokesman-Review newspaper.

Further complicating things, Shawnna Hughes claims her husband is not the child's father.

The bottom line, says Hughes' attorney, Terri Sloyer, is that there's nothing in state law that says a mother can't get a divorce if she's pregnant.

"We don't live in 15th-century England," Sloyer said. "I am absolutely dumbfounded by it."

Hughes' husband, Carlos, was convicted in 2002 of beating her. She separated from him after the attack and filed for divorce last April. She later became pregnant by another man and is due in March.

Her husband never contested the divorce, and Court Commissioner Pro Tem Julia Pelc approved it in late October.


"It's not the child's fault that mom got pregnant," Bastine said. "The answer is, you don't go around doing that when you're not divorced."

Sloyer has appealed.

"This is a very dangerous precedent to set - particularly in this case, with a woman who is a victim of domestic violence," Sloyer said.

Replies: 2 Confessions

Here's a link to a much longer, more in-depth version of that story:

Someone posted it on livejournal and opened up a self-righteous debate about how the woman shouldn't have "gotten knocked up in the first place." Ugh.

Erin @ 01/01/2005 11:16 PM CST

Thanks for that link. What a terrible story. How is forcing this woman to stay married to her abuser in anybody's best interest?

Somehow I doubt that Judge Bastine is what the right wingers have in mind when they complain about "activist judges."

amyc @ 01/02/2005 07:39 AM CST

Add A New Comment

Name (required)

E-Mail (required)

Homepage (optional)

Remember personal info?